The Bainbridge Firm, LLC
Schedule a Free Initial Consultation

Toll Free:866-253-7107

Columbus : 614-545-9990

Portsmouth : 740-353-7548

Ironton :740-532-9772

Marion : 740-387-6727

Cambridge : 740-435-3342

Waverly : 740-835-8890

Springfield : 937-717-9407

Temporary and Permanent at the same time - Advantage Tank Lines

Two of the most common benefits under the Ohio workers' compensation system involve "permanent partial" benefits and "temporary total" benefits.  When an injured worker is not able to return to his or her former position of employment and loses wages as a result, temporary total compensation can be sought to help make up for these lost wages.  Permanent partial benefits, however, can be awarded regardless of whether an injury resulted in lost time.  Expressed as a percentage of whole body impairment, the permanent partial award compensates for the impairment an injured worker has as a result of the allowed conditions.  This type of benefit is completely unrelated to the injured worker's ability to return to work.


Based solely on the names of these benefits, one may think that they cannot be paid at the same time for the same injury.  How can an injury be "permanent" and "temporary" at the same time?  However, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled in Advantage Tank Lines v. Industrial Commission (107 Ohio St.3d 16) that it is not necessarily wrong for a claimant to receive permanent partial and temporary total over the same time for the same injury.


The Court reached this conclusion by noting that these benefits compensate for different things.  Temporary total focuses on lost wages due to disability while permanent partial focuses of bodily impairment. The benefits also have differing perspectives on what it means for something to be permanent.  The Court explained that a condition can be permanent in that there will always be some degree of impairment while at the same time be temporary in the sense that the condition may not always prevent a return to the former position of employment. 

This case has been around since 2005. However, it is remarkable how often it is forgotten when processing an application for either permanent partial or temporary total.    While it may seem odd to assert that something can be both permanent and temporary at the same time, the law in this area is well settled and has been for time.


Bainbridge Firm

580 South High Street

Suite 100

Columbus, OH 43215



No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
email us for a response

Free Initial consultationCall us today for a free initial consultation. We promise to provide a response within a few hours.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


office locations - we have Multiple Locations to serve you.

The Bainbridge Firm, LLC

Columbus Office
900 Michigan Avenue
Columbus, OH 43215

Toll Free: 866-253-7107
Toll Free: 800-762-1612
Phone: 614-545-9990
Fax: 614-224-9300
Map & Directions

Portsmouth Office
611 Court Street
Portsmouth, OH 45662

Toll Free: 866-253-7107
Toll Free: 800-762-1612
Phone: 740-353-7548
Fax: 740-353-1984
Map & Directions

Ironton Office
119 North Fifth Street
Ironton, OH 45638

Toll Free: 866-253-7107
Toll Free: 800-762-1612
Phone: 740-532-9772
Fax: 740-532-3127
Map & Directions

Marion Office
198 East Center Street
Marion, OH 43302

Toll Free: 866-253-7107
Toll Free: 800-762-1612
Phone: 740-387-6727
Fax: 740-382-5816
Map & Directions

Cambridge Office
120 Southgate Parkway
Cambridge, Ohio 43725

Toll Free: 866-253-7107
Toll Free: 800-762-1612
Phone: 740-435-3342
Fax: 740-435-3329
Map & Directions

Waverly Office
112 North Market Street
Suite B
Waverly, OH 45690

Toll Free: 866-253-7107
Toll Free: 800-762-1612
Phone: 740-835-8890
Fax: 740-835-8891
Waverly Law Office Map

Springfield Office
1021 N. Limestone Street
Springfield, OH 45503

Toll Free: 866-253-7107
Toll Free: 800-762-1612
Phone: 937-717-9407
Fax: 937-717-9408
Map & Directions